Eugenics and Family: Difference between revisions

From Dickinson College Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Barbosej (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Barbosej (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Line 15: Line 15:
Although the welfare state in America supports these people, it is also allowing them to increase the population and inject more of these kinds of people into the world which many see as being a major problem with our society today.  Two major points have arisen that some see as being a solution to this problem: birth restrictions for the lower class and genetic engineering to increase the efficiency of the population.   
Although the welfare state in America supports these people, it is also allowing them to increase the population and inject more of these kinds of people into the world which many see as being a major problem with our society today.  Two major points have arisen that some see as being a solution to this problem: birth restrictions for the lower class and genetic engineering to increase the efficiency of the population.   


<bold> Birth Restrictions </bold>





Revision as of 06:04, 5 December 2007

Eugenics, Economics, and the Family

Economics of Eugenics

From a microeconomic perspective, eugenics has the ability to drastically shape the ways in which capital, the labor force and net products are obtained. Almost every person in the has the desire to raise their respective standard of living but can not fully due so due to their genetic make-up. It is absolutely possible that by improving a certain percentage of the population, the standard of living gap between those genetically enhanced and those who are not can make society completely different.

Society today is far from perfect and, even with all the technological advances that claim to improve genes, not everyone will have the opportunity to partake in it causing the income distribution to become more skewed. American citizens from many different ethnic backgrounds have disabilities that may restrict them from achieving a standard of living that some people take for granted:

  • Birth defects
  • Acquired mental/physical diseases
  • Tendencies towards violence, drug addiction, and alcohol

Although the welfare state in America supports these people, it is also allowing them to increase the population and inject more of these kinds of people into the world which many see as being a major problem with our society today. Two major points have arisen that some see as being a solution to this problem: birth restrictions for the lower class and genetic engineering to increase the efficiency of the population.

<bold> Birth Restrictions </bold>


Rationale Behind the German Eugenics Movement

A Bavarian physician by the name of Wilhelm Schallmayer (1857-1919) believed that the eugenics movement in Germany, prior to the rule of Hitler, would raise national efficiency and allow Germany to enter into a superior culture. Unlike many of the so-called eugenicists that followed him, Schallmayer did not fully believe in an Aryan race. He was more concerned with “saving the economically and socially better-situated calsses from biological extinction and his desire to limit the number of unproductive types in the interest of national efficiency were a common denominator uniting both racist and nonracist eugenicists within the German movement”.

Schallmayer focused his eugenic studies on three main areas with which to support his claim:

Social Context- Around the time Schallmayer was studying eugenics, major industrial breakthroughs had taken place in Germany. With these industrial movements came a labor party brought about by Marxist theories which the upper classes viewed as a possible threat along with febble-minded individuals.

Medical Context- Some medical professionals, including Schallmayer, began to look at hereditary in the context of how indivduals develop certain disorders which can negatively affect a society. Many physicians began to promote better gene matching between individuals in order for disorders such as mental illness and epilepsy to be estingished and the German state to grow stronger.

Selectionist Context- Schallmayer began to develop a strong understanding to the work of Darwin. He was able to affiliate natural selection to human beings and look at how the indivduals that did not mesh well with an industrial country were the unfit species.


Modern Eugenics

Society today seems to be engulfed with improving their current situations in life and modeling themselves after others. But what would a specific person constitute as perfect? It could be a physical feature to make them more attractive, an indestructable physice for dominating athletic events, or it could even be as subtle as making people see colors for the first time. When eugenics was brought into the mainstream by Nazi scientists, there was an outcry from people around the world about the Germans trying to create the perfect race. Now, the notion of creating a perfect person free of disease and flaws some how has become a good thing. Enhancements are starting off as a theorputic device in order to help people with certain diseases, but as the American consumer is becoming more willing to pay for anything to help their image, it is only a matter of time before theropy turns to a necessity for the rich.

Along with the monetary aspect of human enhancement, there is the moral and ethical questions of:

  • Why should we do it?
  • Is it worth it?
  • What are the risks involved for myself and others?


Eugenics and the Family

  • Many eugenicists viewed population control as a vehicle for modernization, the introduction of liberal democracy, and, if properly pursued, world peace.
  • Two directions had formed: an outward view focusing on the global framework and an inward view focusing on the family.
  • Many eugenicists blamed racialized population subdivisions, principally those in the Third World, for resource depletion, skyrocketing fertility, and environmental degradation.
  • Negative Eugenics- marriage restrictions, immigration quotas and compulsory sterilizations.
  • Positive Eugenics- concentrated on encouraging those deemed fit to reproduce in higher numbers.



Eugenics | Eugenics, Economics, and the Family | People of Tomorrow | Possibilities and Problems | Requirements Now for the Future