International Relations Theory: Difference between revisions

From Dickinson College Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Traditional Idealist's''' – norms, ideals, and interests can be achieved naturally through cooperation
Traditional Idealists – norms, ideals, and interests can be achieved naturally through cooperation
'''Woodrow Wilson''' – staunch supporter of free trade, open agreements and treaties, self determination
Woodrow Wilson – staunch supporter of free trade, open agreements and treaties, self determination
British 19th century liberals believed that the state protects interests, there is natural determination, and due to free trade war has become an outdated waste of resources.  (Manchester school – war wastes times and money; free trade aids and profits all)
British 19th century liberals believed that the state protects interests, there is natural determination, and due to free trade war has become an outdated waste of resources.  (Manchester school – war wastes times and money; free trade aids and profits all)


'''Realists''' – Bismark, Machiavelli, Kissinger – analyze politics in terms of power; conflict is the natural way of things
'''Leviathan''' Hobbes – subterfuge is the way to survive, there is no place for principles. All men are the same and predisposed to want the same things, and this leads to war and violence.  Those who claim peace are simply afraid of death.
State of Nature/State of War all against all and there is competition because everyone wants to
Absolute gains
The total benefits that accrue to a state as a consequence of its interactions with other states without regard to the benefits that accrue to others. Liberals argue that states are the most concerned with absolute gains and that they provide a basis for cooperation in world politics. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova


'''State of Nature'''/'''State of War''' all against all and there is competition because everyone wants to
Anarchy is the simple reality that within the international system composed of nation states, there exists no overarching authority. Each state maintains its own autonomy with respect to every other state; no international government exists. This renders the system chaotic and unpredictable, but not necessarily destined for conflict.
See: John Mersheimer, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, Kenneth Waltz, The Anarchic Structure of World Politics, Hobbes
Absence of poitical hierarchy and central authoriy


'''Absolute gains''' The total benefits that accrue to a state as a consequence of its interactions with other states without regard to the benefits that accrue to others. Liberals argue that states are the most concerned with absolute gains and that they provide a basis for cooperation in world politics. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova
Appeasement
The act of making compromises or concessions in order to avoid a potentially costly war. The most common example would be the actions on the part of Great Britain toward Nazi Germany in the build up to World War II.


'''Anarchy''' is the simple reality that within the international system composed of nation states, there exists no overarching authority. Each state maintains its own autonomy with respect to every other state; no international government exists. This renders the system chaotic and unpredictable, but not necessarily destined for conflict.
Autarky
See: John Mersheimer, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, Kenneth Waltz, The Anarchic Structure of World Politics


'"Appeasement'" The act of making compromises or concessions in order to avoid a potentially costly war. The most common example would be the actions on the part of Great Britain toward Nazi Germany in the build up to World War II.
Autarky is the ability to be self-sufficient. It is most commonly used when referring to economics, when a country can survive without external assistance. Autarky does not have to refer to economics though. A military autarky would be one that could defend itself without outside help.


'''Autarky''' the ability to be self-sufficient. It is most commonly used when referring to economics, when a country can survive without external assistance. Autarky does not have to refer to economics though. A military autarky would be one that could defend itself without outside help.
Bipolarity
 
Two major global superpowers that dominate the international system, struggling to find the balance of power. This was a huge component during the Cold War.
'''Clash of Civilizations'''
Clash of Civilizations
Samuel Huntington, presents us with a post-cold war paradigm: that increasingly, geopolitics delineate themselves along broad culture boundaries. All modern conflicts are the result of this "clash of civilizations." These conflicts are all the more irreconcilable as they are related to culture and identity. Huntington identifies seven distinct "civilizations": sinic, or Chinese civilization, Japanese, Hindu, Islamic, Orthodox, centered in Russia, Western and Latin America. He also concedes that there may be an African civilization, but, and I quote: "most major scholars of civilization except Braudel do not recognize a distinct African civilization."
Samuel Huntington, presents us with a post-cold war paradigm: that increasingly, geopolitics delineate themselves along broad culture boundaries. All modern conflicts are the result of this "clash of civilizations." These conflicts are all the more irreconcilable as they are related to culture and identity. Huntington identifies seven distinct "civilizations": sinic, or Chinese civilization, Japanese, Hindu, Islamic, Orthodox, centered in Russia, Western and Latin America. He also concedes that there may be an African civilization, but, and I quote: "most major scholars of civilization except Braudel do not recognize a distinct African civilization."
See: Samuel Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking World Order
See: Samuel Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking World Order


'''Democratic Peace Theory'''
Cold War- 1945-1995- escalation of tensions between the two superpowers in a bipolar post WWII world.
 
Democratic Peace Theory
 
Based on the empirical observation that democracies have historically tended not to fight wars against one another, this theory suggests that the spread of democratic government can be the antidote to war in the international system. Proponents of this theory point to either democratic norms (such as a shared belief in human rights) or actual democratic political structures to explain the lesser incidence of war between democracies. This concept is highly debated. Realists suggest that this phenomenon is actually caused by the prevalence of alliance ties between democracies, which are a function of realist power concerns. John Mearshimer (a prominent realist) has suggested that democracies are few in number and thus statistically have less opportunities to go to war. For a good analysis of the validity of the democratic peace theory, see this article.
Based on the empirical observation that democracies have historically tended not to fight wars against one another, this theory suggests that the spread of democratic government can be the antidote to war in the international system. Proponents of this theory point to either democratic norms (such as a shared belief in human rights) or actual democratic political structures to explain the lesser incidence of war between democracies. This concept is highly debated. Realists suggest that this phenomenon is actually caused by the prevalence of alliance ties between democracies, which are a function of realist power concerns. John Mearshimer (a prominent realist) has suggested that democracies are few in number and thus statistically have less opportunities to go to war. For a good analysis of the validity of the democratic peace theory, see this article.


'''Dependency theory'''
Dependency theory: Component of structuralism/neo Marxism. The idea that the periphery does not benefit from liberal international economic order, it is instead dependent on the core. The relationship between the core and the periphery relationship is exploitative, promoting development of the core but not the periphery. The core relies on periphery markets and so establishes structures that perpetuate core dominance. Local elites monopolize domestic power and cooperate with international capitalist elites to perpetuate capitalist system.
Component of structuralism/neo Marxism. The idea that the periphery does not benefit from liberal international economic order, it is instead dependent on the core. The relationship between the core and the periphery relationship is exploitative, promoting development of the core but not the periphery. The core relies on periphery markets and so establishes structures that perpetuate core dominance. Local elites monopolize domestic power and cooperate with international capitalist elites to perpetuate capitalist system.
 
Détente


'"Détente'"
This word comes from the French, meaning a "relaxation of tensions." In political science, the term specifically refers to the relaxation of Cold War tensions that took place between the US and the Soviet Union during the 1970s. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova
This word comes from the French, meaning a "relaxation of tensions." In political science, the term specifically refers to the relaxation of Cold War tensions that took place between the US and the Soviet Union during the 1970s. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova


'"Export-led growth'"
Export-led growth: becomes the ruling model for South by 1980s-1990s. Founded on the idea that export growth in conjunction with protectionism will lead to maximized production efficiency, increased earnings, and increase in foreign exchange for development. This strategy was aimed at expanding overseas markets to the North by improving competition abroad. This was done by diversifying domestic export industries and industrializing. The central idea was to develop the economy in such a way that it would strongly appeal to foreign, developed markets. South switched to this model of growth following the failures of the NIEO and ISI strategy, the success of Asian tigers, and Northern pressures to liberalize under the Washington Consensus.
becomes the ruling model for South by 1980s-1990s. Founded on the idea that export growth in conjunction with protectionism will lead to maximized production efficiency, increased earnings, and increase in foreign exchange for development. This strategy was aimed at expanding overseas markets to the North by improving competition abroad. This was done by diversifying domestic export industries and industrializing. The central idea was to develop the economy in such a way that it would strongly appeal to foreign, developed markets. South switched to this model of growth following the failures of the NIEO and ISI strategy, the success of Asian tigers, and Northern pressures to liberalize under the Washington Consensus.


'"Feminism'"
Feminism-- this is the theory that international relations would be different if more women were in power positions, and that politics is traditionally viewed through a male perspective.
this is the theory that international relations would be different if more women were in power positions, and that politics is traditionally viewed through a male perspective.


'"Glastnost and perestroika'"
Free Trade-breaks down trade barriers and creates international connections which lead to new interests and priorities in the hopes of World peace
are, respectively, the policies of “openness” and “restructuring,” which Mikhail Gorbachev pursued as a general secretary of the Communist Party of the USSR between 1985 and 1991, which had the aim of complementing one another towards renovating the Soviet political system and society.
 
Glastnost and perestroika: are, respectively, the policies of “openness” and “restructuring,” which Mikhail Gorbachev pursued as a general secretary of the Communist Party of the USSR between 1985 and 1991, which had the aim of complementing one another towards renovating the Soviet political system and society.
Glastnost was analogous to the freedom of speech and publication. Its immediate effect was and an flux of reports about corruption and criminality as well as state crimes, while perestroika encouraged political democratization through an introduction of contested election and new political institutions, as well as economic liberalization through legalization of cooperative and other semi-private business enterprises.
Glastnost was analogous to the freedom of speech and publication. Its immediate effect was and an flux of reports about corruption and criminality as well as state crimes, while perestroika encouraged political democratization through an introduction of contested election and new political institutions, as well as economic liberalization through legalization of cooperative and other semi-private business enterprises.
The policies had a catastrophic effect on Gorbachev’s political career, because they undermined public confidence in his ability to govern successfully. See this article.
The policies had a catastrophic effect on Gorbachev’s political career, because they undermined public confidence in his ability to govern successfully. See this article.


'"Groupthink'"
Groupthink
The tendency, most often found in small, cohesive groups operating under conditions of stress, to abandon critical thinking in favor of viewpoints that reflect group solidarity. The term was coined by William Whyte, who claimed it was a "rationalized conformity—an open, articulate philosophy which holds that group values are not only expedient but right and good as well." The most prominent researcher of groupthink was Irving Janis. Some scholars would point to the Bush administration and certain of its poor decisions as an example of this occurence. See this article from the New York Times, or this book review which gives a concise and thorough overview of the topic.
The tendency, most often found in small, cohesive groups operating under conditions of stress, to abandon critical thinking in favor of viewpoints that reflect group solidarity. The term was coined by William Whyte, who claimed it was a "rationalized conformity—an open, articulate philosophy which holds that group values are not only expedient but right and good as well." The most prominent researcher of groupthink was Irving Janis. Some scholars would point to the Bush administration and certain of its poor decisions as an example of this occurence. See this article from the New York Times, or this book review which gives a concise and thorough overview of the topic.


'"Human Rights'"
Human Rights;
the definition of human or natural rights as the rights of each person simply as a human being specifies their character; they are rights. For the question of "what is it in human nature that gives rise to human rights?", there are two basic answers; that HR arise from human nees; and HR reflect the minimum requirements for human dignity or moral personality.  
the definition of human or natural rights as the rights of each person simply as a human being specifies their character; they are rights. For the question of "what is it in human nature that gives rise to human rights?", there are two basic answers; that HR arise from human nees; and HR reflect the minimum requirements for human dignity or moral personality.  
From: "Human Rights in World Politics" from International Politics by Art and Jervis.
From: "Human Rights in World Politics" from International Politics by Art and Jervis.


'"IBRD'"
IBRD: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, known as IBRD, is one of the five institutions that comprise the World Bank Group, including the 1) International Development Association, 2) International Finance Corporation, 3) Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency and 4) International Center for Settlement of International Disputes
The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, known as IBRD, is one of the five institutions that comprise the World Bank Group, including the 1) International Development Association, 2) International Finance Corporation, 3) Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency and 4) International Center for Settlement of International Disputes
The Banks was established immediately after the WWII to foster economic growth in post-war Europe and Japan. Today, its main goal is to fight poverty and encourage sustainable development through extension of loans to creditworthy governments and public enterprises. The bank raises its funds by selling its bonds on the world’s financial markets.
The Banks was established immediately after the WWII to foster economic growth in post-war Europe and Japan. Today, its main goal is to fight poverty and encourage sustainable development through extension of loans to creditworthy governments and public enterprises. The bank raises its funds by selling its bonds on the world’s financial markets.
Source: www.worldbank.org
Source: www.worldbank.org


'"Idealism'"
Idealism;
it usually analyses politics in terms of 'norms' and 'ideals' as well as 'interests.' Idealism tends toward optimistic view of human nature and society, seeing cooperation as not only desirable but natural
it usually analyses politics in terms of 'norms' and 'ideals' as well as 'interests.' Idealism tends toward optimistic view of human nature and society, seeing cooperation as not only desirable but natural


Import substitution industrialization: designed to reduce imports via tariffs, quotas, multiple exchange rates, etc. The goal is to protect infant industries, allowing them to develop and grow, ultimately encouraging FDI. This strategy encourages diversification toward manufacturing and is biased toward exports. The strategy tends to start with production of consumer goods and evolve toward capital goods. Another facet of this strategy involves the purposeful overvaluation of currency so that foreigners can’t easily import your goods, making imports of selective components cheaper. This strategy fails to generate capital savings sufficient to finance the transition to capital goods production. So ISI does not necessarily lead to decline in imports, rather it changes the composition of imports. Ultimately, ISI produces balance of trade deficits and creates weak, non-internationally competitive industries while weakening traditional exports. By the 1970s, the developing world realized that ISI was no longer a viable economic strategy.
Import substitution industrialization: designed to reduce imports via tariffs, quotas, multiple exchange rates, etc. The goal is to protect infant industries, allowing them to develop and grow, ultimately encouraging FDI. This strategy encourages diversification toward manufacturing and is biased toward exports. The strategy tends to start with production of consumer goods and evolve toward capital goods. Another facet of this strategy involves the purposeful overvaluation of currency so that foreigners can’t easily import your goods, making imports of selective components cheaper. This strategy fails to generate capital savings sufficient to finance the transition to capital goods production. So ISI does not necessarily lead to decline in imports, rather it changes the composition of imports. Ultimately, ISI produces balance of trade deficits and creates weak, non-internationally competitive industries while weakening traditional exports. By the 1970s, the developing world realized that ISI was no longer a viable economic strategy.


'"IMF'"
IMF
The International Monetary Fund was founded in 1944 as a part of the Bretton Woods Accord, to calm and solidify the international political economy. The IMF was a permanent institution to monitor a fixed currency, the “Gold Standard” which levied all international currencies off of the US dollar, which in turn was calculated from a specific weight of gold. As an observing body, the IMF intervened whenever a country’s currency fluctuated from more than one percent difference from the US dollar. The function of the IMF had to shift with the end of the Gold Standard. The IMF still serves to prevent crisis with emergency financing, but also to provide advice and to serve as a forum. All members donate a monetary quota that is calculated based on their relative wealth. This amount determines both the weight of their vote and the amount that they can be loaned. Members can borrow up to twenty-five percent of their quota and this is part of the new function of the IMF: that it buys out countries when they are close to defaulting on national loans, and the country is required to pay back the loan in their own currency with interest.
The International Monetary Fund was founded in 1944 as a part of the Bretton Woods Accord, to calm and solidify the international political economy. The IMF was a permanent institution to monitor a fixed currency, the “Gold Standard” which levied all international currencies off of the US dollar, which in turn was calculated from a specific weight of gold. As an observing body, the IMF intervened whenever a country’s currency fluctuated from more than one percent difference from the US dollar. The function of the IMF had to shift with the end of the Gold Standard. The IMF still serves to prevent crisis with emergency financing, but also to provide advice and to serve as a forum. All members donate a monetary quota that is calculated based on their relative wealth. This amount determines both the weight of their vote and the amount that they can be loaned. Members can borrow up to twenty-five percent of their quota and this is part of the new function of the IMF: that it buys out countries when they are close to defaulting on national loans, and the country is required to pay back the loan in their own currency with interest.
See: http://www.imf.org/external/index.htm
See: http://www.imf.org/external/index.htm


'''Just War''' – Aquinas & St Augustine – there is authority of a sovereign; a random citizen may not declare war.  There must be just cause – a valid reason to avenge wrong and right injustice; and rightful intention to advance good and fight evil.
Just War – Aquinas & St Augustine – there is authority of a sovereign; a random citizen may not declare war.  There must be just cause – a valid reason to avenge wrong and right injustice; and rightful intention to advance good and fight evil.
Grotius expanded on this theory by saying that a just war can be ended as soon as possible, since the losses dues to war do not make it profitable.  Sacrifice interests for peace; not war.
Grotius expanded on this theory by saying that a just war can be ended as soon as possible, since the losses dues to war do not make it profitable.  Sacrifice interests for peace; not war.


'"Mutual Assured Destruction (MAD)'"
Leviathan – Hobbes – subterfuge is the way to survive, there is no place for principles.  All men are the same and predisposed to want the same things, and this leads to war and violence.  Those who claim peace are simply afraid of death.
-men are equal unitis
-men interact with no central authority
-men are driven by certain motives: compitition, diffidnce-fear of losing something, and glory
-Life is brutis and short with no right and wrong. No common power, law or justice
 
"Liberal internationalism"
belief in international principles, trade to prevent war. Ideas derived from Kant.
 
Liberal Institutionalism
The belief in international institutions and an inter-governmental body that has continuity in relations, trade, sanctions and embargoes, Reciprocity to address grievences, and a source of flow of information and technology.This model is non-state centric.
 
Mutual Assured Destruction (MAD)
A condition of mutual deterrence in which, in the event of a nuclear war, each side has the capability to inflict an unacceptable damage on the other. Thus, neither side would presumably initiate the use of nuclear weapons. This situation necessitates both sides having sufficent weapons to retaliate (see second strike capability). From: How the World Works by Russell Bova
A condition of mutual deterrence in which, in the event of a nuclear war, each side has the capability to inflict an unacceptable damage on the other. Thus, neither side would presumably initiate the use of nuclear weapons. This situation necessitates both sides having sufficent weapons to retaliate (see second strike capability). From: How the World Works by Russell Bova


'"NATO'"
Nation, State, and Nation-state
Nation-formed through the involvement of cultural, religious, and ethnic ties, not ideals
State- primary actor in international relations. Components of a State: 1. Permanent population 2. Recognition from other countries 3.Defined territory 4.government capable of maintaining border. A state must be have a monopoly on the use of force and the power of taxation.
Nation-state-the civic mechanics of a state combined with the ties of ethnic groups
 
NATO
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (or OTAN in French) is the intergovernmental military alliance that was created in 1949 at the advent of the Cold War. It was the first contract of collective security that the US participated in. One of the immediate reactions was the creation of the Warsaw Pact between the Soviet bloc countries. The fundamental structure and function of the NATO alliance was the West against the Soviet Union, but has shifted since the fall of the Berlin Wall. NATO first saw action during the Korean War. France was resentful of the prominent roles of the US and Great Britain, and withdrew from the military component of the alliance in 1959. As the Cold War escalated, NATO played a consistent role, upholding the policies of détente, etc. At the end of the Cold War, NATO quickly became integrally involved in the crises in the Balkans. NATO had the flexibility to react with military might when the UN could not. There are currently 28 independent members from North America and Europe, who are committed to upholding the freedom and security of all the member states.
North Atlantic Treaty Organization (or OTAN in French) is the intergovernmental military alliance that was created in 1949 at the advent of the Cold War. It was the first contract of collective security that the US participated in. One of the immediate reactions was the creation of the Warsaw Pact between the Soviet bloc countries. The fundamental structure and function of the NATO alliance was the West against the Soviet Union, but has shifted since the fall of the Berlin Wall. NATO first saw action during the Korean War. France was resentful of the prominent roles of the US and Great Britain, and withdrew from the military component of the alliance in 1959. As the Cold War escalated, NATO played a consistent role, upholding the policies of détente, etc. At the end of the Cold War, NATO quickly became integrally involved in the crises in the Balkans. NATO had the flexibility to react with military might when the UN could not. There are currently 28 independent members from North America and Europe, who are committed to upholding the freedom and security of all the member states.
See: http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/index.htm
See: http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/index.htm


'"Milennium Development Goals'"
Non-tariff barriers (NTBs): non-tariff forms of restricting trade. These NTBs discriminate against imports and represent an exception to the free trade concept instituted under the GATT. Forms of NTBs include quotas, anti-dumping legislation, voluntary export restraints, and orderly market agreements, which are effectively multi-country VERs.
 
Marxism
1920-1990 founded by Karl Marx wrote the "communist manifesto" explaining how to live in a communist society
 
Milennium Development Goals
In September 2000, world leaders came together at United Nations Headquarters in New York to adopt the United Nations Milennium Declaration, committing their nations to a new global partnership to reduce extreme poverty and setting out a series of time-bound targets - with a deadline of 2015 - that have become known as the Millennium Development Goals.
In September 2000, world leaders came together at United Nations Headquarters in New York to adopt the United Nations Milennium Declaration, committing their nations to a new global partnership to reduce extreme poverty and setting out a series of time-bound targets - with a deadline of 2015 - that have become known as the Millennium Development Goals.
See: http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/bkgd.shtml
See: http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/bkgd.shtml


'"Non-tariff barriers (NTBs)'"
Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC): cartel in which many members are among the largest global exporters of oil. The purpose of OPEC is to regulate the supply of petroleum and thereby stabilize (often by raising) its price. OPEC was ascendant between 1973 and 1980 because of increased competition within the petroleum industry, increased producer-state bargaining, and increased oil dependency of the developed world. Saudi Arabia served as the lynchpin within OPEC, serving as a swing producer.
non-tariff forms of restricting trade. These NTBs discriminate against imports and represent an exception to the free trade concept instituted under the GATT. Forms of NTBs include quotas, anti-dumping legislation, voluntary export restraints, and orderly market agreements, which are effectively multi-country VERs.


'"Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)'"
Peak Oil: where production is dwindling to levels inadequate to meet demand, which produces price spikes. Production can dwindle for a number of reasons included geology, environmental concerns regarding extraction, and the age of tough oil (oil is less accessible due to geopolitics).  
cartel in which many members are among the largest global exporters of oil. The purpose of OPEC is to regulate the supply of petroleum and thereby stabilize (often by raising) its price. OPEC was ascendant between 1973 and 1980 because of increased competition within the petroleum industry, increased producer-state bargaining, and increased oil dependency of the developed world. Saudi Arabia served as the lynchpin within OPEC, serving as a swing producer.


'"Peak Oil'"
Positive-sum: scenario in which all parties can gain or profit. In the liberal model of comparative advantage, through trade, all parties can benefit. In this scenario, one’s gain is not another’s loss. This scenario considers absolute gains, whereby you are better off than you were before, as opposed to relative gains.
where production is dwindling to levels inadequate to meet demand, which produces price spikes. Production can dwindle for a number of reasons included geology, environmental concerns regarding extraction, and the age of tough oil (oil is less accessible due to geopolitics).  


'"Positive-sum'"
Realpolitik: refers to a type of foreign policy, according to which concern for the security of the state (raison d’etat) is primary to any other concern, including ideology or moral dilemmas. Realpolitik also calls for pragmatism in calculating power and national interests by building military capabilities, creating alliances, or making concessions, which also reduce the chance of conflict.
scenario in which all parties can gain or profit. In the liberal model of comparative advantage, through trade, all parties can benefit. In this scenario, one’s gain is not another’s loss. This scenario considers absolute gains, whereby you are better off than you were before, as opposed to relative gains.


'"Realpolitik'"
refers to a type of foreign policy, according to which concern for the security of the state (raison d’etat) is primary to any other concern, including ideology or moral dilemmas. Realpolitik also calls for pragmatism in calculating power and national interests by building military capabilities, creating alliances, or making concessions, which also reduce the chance of conflict.
See definition in this article
See definition in this article


'"Realism'"
Realism;
it analyses politics in terms of 'interests' as power. Realism tends toward a passimistic view of human nature and society, seeing conflict as inherent and inevitable.
it analyses politics in terms of 'interests' as power. Realism tends toward a passimistic view of human nature and society, seeing conflict as inherent and inevitable.  
Classical Realism- Morganthaw- anarchy is assumed as a prominent concern in international relations,with the international system as the focus of analysis. States are hard-wired for power they seek more and more powerand this leads to war.
-power is mans control over the minds and actions of other men
-international relations is a struggle for power
-states cannot die for a moral reason and cannot sacrifice themselves
-no morality in international politics
States are suspicious of other states, calculated, prudent and cautious, no permanent friends or enemies only permanent interests
Neo-realism: Waltz- realism is a description of a system and states are trapped in a structure. like the classical realists, neorealist believe that anarchy exists. Countries create a distribution of capabilities and power--> relative gain. The primary goal is survival and the focus of analysis is power, and there is a clear distincition between domestic and international politics:
-International Politics: states are actors, there is a lack of hierarchy, all states behave the same no matter their structure of government
-Domestic politics: not all groups are egual, they are different units
Realists – Bismark, Machiavelli, Kissinger – analyze politics in terms of power; conflict is the natural way of things
 
Relative gains


'"Relative gains''"
The benefits that accrue to a state from its international interactions assessed in comparision to the benefits that accrue to other states. Realists argue that states are most concerned with relative gains and that this concern is a source of tension and conflict in world politics. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova
The benefits that accrue to a state from its international interactions assessed in comparision to the benefits that accrue to other states. Realists argue that states are most concerned with relative gains and that this concern is a source of tension and conflict in world politics. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova


'"Second strike capability'"
Second strike capability
The ability of a country with nuclear weapons to ride out an initial nuclear attack with enough retalitory capability left intact to do unacceptable damage to one's adversary. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova
The ability of a country with nuclear weapons to ride out an initial nuclear attack with enough retalitory capability left intact to do unacceptable damage to one's adversary. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova


'"Waltz's "Three Images" of International Relation'"
Waltz's "Three Images" of International Relation
In 1959, Waltz's book "Man, the State, and War" attempted to formulate a structural realist theory which classified theories of international relations into three categories, or levels of analysis.
In 1959, Waltz's book "Man, the State, and War" attempted to formulate a structural realist theory which classified theories of international relations into three categories, or levels of analysis.
1st Image: Individual, Human Nature.
1st Image: Individual, Human Nature.
2nd Image: State, Regime, Type.
3rd Image: System level (as a whole).


2nd Image: State, Regime, Type.
Uses of Force: For the following definitions see: International Politics, enduring Concepts and Contemporary Issues by R. Art and R. Jervis.


3rd Image: System level (as a whole).
Defense: The defensive use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to do two things - to ward off an attack and to minimize damage to oneself if attacked. For defensive purposes a state will direct its forces against those of a potential or actual attacker, but not against his unarmed population.


'"Uses of Force'"
Deterrence: The deterrent use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to prevent an adversary from doing something that he does not want him to do and that he might otherwise be tempted to do by threatening him with unacceptable punishment is he does. Deterrence is thus the threat of retaliation.Its purpose is to prevent something undesirable from happening. The effectiveness of the threatvdepends upon a sate's ability to to convince a potential adversary that it has both the will and the power to punish him severely if he undertakes the undesirable action in question.
For the following definitions see: International Politics, enduring Concepts and Contemporary Issues by R. Art and R. Jervis.


'"Defense'" -The defensive use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to do two things - to ward off an attack and to minimize damage to oneself if attacked. For defensive purposes a state will direct its forces against those of a potential or actual attacker, but not against his unarmed population.
Peloponnesian War:
Greece 431-404bc. Thucydides was the first to write a purely human viewpoint in which he explianed the cause of the war was a distribution of power. REpresentation of Realist ideals. Struggle between Athen and Sparta because Sparta felt that Athens had become too powerful, the Coreyra/Corinth dispute, the sacking of pontideaea, and trade sanctions on Pegara
Security Dilemma: A country can never fully know the intentions of its neighbors, making defensive measures appear threatening or aggressive, creating the security dilemma. This frequently leads to arms races, even if the countries involved have no intention of using force.


'"Deterrence'" -The deterrent use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to prevent an adversary from doing something that he does not want him to do and that he might otherwise be tempted to do by threatening him with unacceptable punishment is he does. Deterrence is thus the threat of retaliation.Its purpose is to prevent something undesirable from happening. The effectiveness of the threatvdepends upon a sate's ability to to convince a potential adversary that it has both the will and the power to punish him severely if he undertakes the undesirable action in question.
Sovereignty- comes from within a territory, having the authority to establish and enforce its own rules


'"Swaggering'" -The objectives for swaggering are more diffuse. Generally swaggering involves only the peaceful use of force and it aims to enhace the national pride of a people or two to satisfy the personal ambitions of its ruler. A state or a statesman swaggers in order to loo and feel more powerful and important, to be taken seriously by the others.
Swaggering: The objectives for swaggering are more diffuse. Generally swaggering involves only the peaceful use of force and it aims to enhace the national pride of a people or two to satisfy the personal ambitions of its ruler. A state or a statesman swaggers in order to loo and feel more powerful and important, to be taken seriously by the others.


'"Security Dilemma'" -A country can never fully know the intentions of its neighbors, making defensive measures appear threatening or aggressive, creating the security dilemma. This frequently leads to arms races, even if the countries involved have no intention of using force.
Treaty of Westophalia- 1648 ended the 30 years War, defined regions and abolished the hierarchy


'"Washington consensus'" -set of principles that informed economic liberalization policies of South in 1990s. Some of these principles were forced on the South by coercive actions of the U.S. or structural adjustment/austerity programs imposed by the World Bank and IMF. Others were adopted voluntarily. The consensus was focused on fiscal discipline, spending on public goods, tax reform, privatization, and deregulation.
Washington consensus: set of principles that informed economic liberalization policies of South in 1990s. Some of these principles were forced on the South by coercive actions of the U.S. or structural adjustment/austerity programs imposed by the World Bank and IMF. Others were adopted voluntarily. The consensus was focused on fiscal discipline, spending on public goods, tax reform, privatization, and deregulation.

Revision as of 05:40, 5 February 2010

Traditional Idealists – norms, ideals, and interests can be achieved naturally through cooperation Woodrow Wilson – staunch supporter of free trade, open agreements and treaties, self determination British 19th century liberals believed that the state protects interests, there is natural determination, and due to free trade war has become an outdated waste of resources. (Manchester school – war wastes times and money; free trade aids and profits all)


State of Nature/State of War – all against all and there is competition because everyone wants to Absolute gains The total benefits that accrue to a state as a consequence of its interactions with other states without regard to the benefits that accrue to others. Liberals argue that states are the most concerned with absolute gains and that they provide a basis for cooperation in world politics. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova

Anarchy is the simple reality that within the international system composed of nation states, there exists no overarching authority. Each state maintains its own autonomy with respect to every other state; no international government exists. This renders the system chaotic and unpredictable, but not necessarily destined for conflict. See: John Mersheimer, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics, Kenneth Waltz, The Anarchic Structure of World Politics, Hobbes Absence of poitical hierarchy and central authoriy

Appeasement The act of making compromises or concessions in order to avoid a potentially costly war. The most common example would be the actions on the part of Great Britain toward Nazi Germany in the build up to World War II.

Autarky

Autarky is the ability to be self-sufficient. It is most commonly used when referring to economics, when a country can survive without external assistance. Autarky does not have to refer to economics though. A military autarky would be one that could defend itself without outside help.

Bipolarity Two major global superpowers that dominate the international system, struggling to find the balance of power. This was a huge component during the Cold War. Clash of Civilizations Samuel Huntington, presents us with a post-cold war paradigm: that increasingly, geopolitics delineate themselves along broad culture boundaries. All modern conflicts are the result of this "clash of civilizations." These conflicts are all the more irreconcilable as they are related to culture and identity. Huntington identifies seven distinct "civilizations": sinic, or Chinese civilization, Japanese, Hindu, Islamic, Orthodox, centered in Russia, Western and Latin America. He also concedes that there may be an African civilization, but, and I quote: "most major scholars of civilization except Braudel do not recognize a distinct African civilization." See: Samuel Huntington, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking World Order

Cold War- 1945-1995- escalation of tensions between the two superpowers in a bipolar post WWII world.

Democratic Peace Theory

Based on the empirical observation that democracies have historically tended not to fight wars against one another, this theory suggests that the spread of democratic government can be the antidote to war in the international system. Proponents of this theory point to either democratic norms (such as a shared belief in human rights) or actual democratic political structures to explain the lesser incidence of war between democracies. This concept is highly debated. Realists suggest that this phenomenon is actually caused by the prevalence of alliance ties between democracies, which are a function of realist power concerns. John Mearshimer (a prominent realist) has suggested that democracies are few in number and thus statistically have less opportunities to go to war. For a good analysis of the validity of the democratic peace theory, see this article.

Dependency theory: Component of structuralism/neo Marxism. The idea that the periphery does not benefit from liberal international economic order, it is instead dependent on the core. The relationship between the core and the periphery relationship is exploitative, promoting development of the core but not the periphery. The core relies on periphery markets and so establishes structures that perpetuate core dominance. Local elites monopolize domestic power and cooperate with international capitalist elites to perpetuate capitalist system.

Détente

This word comes from the French, meaning a "relaxation of tensions." In political science, the term specifically refers to the relaxation of Cold War tensions that took place between the US and the Soviet Union during the 1970s. Taken from: How the World Works by Russell Bova

Export-led growth: becomes the ruling model for South by 1980s-1990s. Founded on the idea that export growth in conjunction with protectionism will lead to maximized production efficiency, increased earnings, and increase in foreign exchange for development. This strategy was aimed at expanding overseas markets to the North by improving competition abroad. This was done by diversifying domestic export industries and industrializing. The central idea was to develop the economy in such a way that it would strongly appeal to foreign, developed markets. South switched to this model of growth following the failures of the NIEO and ISI strategy, the success of Asian tigers, and Northern pressures to liberalize under the Washington Consensus.

Feminism-- this is the theory that international relations would be different if more women were in power positions, and that politics is traditionally viewed through a male perspective.

Free Trade-breaks down trade barriers and creates international connections which lead to new interests and priorities in the hopes of World peace

Glastnost and perestroika: are, respectively, the policies of “openness” and “restructuring,” which Mikhail Gorbachev pursued as a general secretary of the Communist Party of the USSR between 1985 and 1991, which had the aim of complementing one another towards renovating the Soviet political system and society. Glastnost was analogous to the freedom of speech and publication. Its immediate effect was and an flux of reports about corruption and criminality as well as state crimes, while perestroika encouraged political democratization through an introduction of contested election and new political institutions, as well as economic liberalization through legalization of cooperative and other semi-private business enterprises. The policies had a catastrophic effect on Gorbachev’s political career, because they undermined public confidence in his ability to govern successfully. See this article.

Groupthink The tendency, most often found in small, cohesive groups operating under conditions of stress, to abandon critical thinking in favor of viewpoints that reflect group solidarity. The term was coined by William Whyte, who claimed it was a "rationalized conformity—an open, articulate philosophy which holds that group values are not only expedient but right and good as well." The most prominent researcher of groupthink was Irving Janis. Some scholars would point to the Bush administration and certain of its poor decisions as an example of this occurence. See this article from the New York Times, or this book review which gives a concise and thorough overview of the topic.

Human Rights; the definition of human or natural rights as the rights of each person simply as a human being specifies their character; they are rights. For the question of "what is it in human nature that gives rise to human rights?", there are two basic answers; that HR arise from human nees; and HR reflect the minimum requirements for human dignity or moral personality. From: "Human Rights in World Politics" from International Politics by Art and Jervis.

IBRD: The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development, known as IBRD, is one of the five institutions that comprise the World Bank Group, including the 1) International Development Association, 2) International Finance Corporation, 3) Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency and 4) International Center for Settlement of International Disputes The Banks was established immediately after the WWII to foster economic growth in post-war Europe and Japan. Today, its main goal is to fight poverty and encourage sustainable development through extension of loans to creditworthy governments and public enterprises. The bank raises its funds by selling its bonds on the world’s financial markets. Source: www.worldbank.org

Idealism; it usually analyses politics in terms of 'norms' and 'ideals' as well as 'interests.' Idealism tends toward optimistic view of human nature and society, seeing cooperation as not only desirable but natural

Import substitution industrialization: designed to reduce imports via tariffs, quotas, multiple exchange rates, etc. The goal is to protect infant industries, allowing them to develop and grow, ultimately encouraging FDI. This strategy encourages diversification toward manufacturing and is biased toward exports. The strategy tends to start with production of consumer goods and evolve toward capital goods. Another facet of this strategy involves the purposeful overvaluation of currency so that foreigners can’t easily import your goods, making imports of selective components cheaper. This strategy fails to generate capital savings sufficient to finance the transition to capital goods production. So ISI does not necessarily lead to decline in imports, rather it changes the composition of imports. Ultimately, ISI produces balance of trade deficits and creates weak, non-internationally competitive industries while weakening traditional exports. By the 1970s, the developing world realized that ISI was no longer a viable economic strategy.

IMF The International Monetary Fund was founded in 1944 as a part of the Bretton Woods Accord, to calm and solidify the international political economy. The IMF was a permanent institution to monitor a fixed currency, the “Gold Standard” which levied all international currencies off of the US dollar, which in turn was calculated from a specific weight of gold. As an observing body, the IMF intervened whenever a country’s currency fluctuated from more than one percent difference from the US dollar. The function of the IMF had to shift with the end of the Gold Standard. The IMF still serves to prevent crisis with emergency financing, but also to provide advice and to serve as a forum. All members donate a monetary quota that is calculated based on their relative wealth. This amount determines both the weight of their vote and the amount that they can be loaned. Members can borrow up to twenty-five percent of their quota and this is part of the new function of the IMF: that it buys out countries when they are close to defaulting on national loans, and the country is required to pay back the loan in their own currency with interest. See: http://www.imf.org/external/index.htm

Just War – Aquinas & St Augustine – there is authority of a sovereign; a random citizen may not declare war. There must be just cause – a valid reason to avenge wrong and right injustice; and rightful intention to advance good and fight evil. Grotius expanded on this theory by saying that a just war can be ended as soon as possible, since the losses dues to war do not make it profitable. Sacrifice interests for peace; not war.

Leviathan – Hobbes – subterfuge is the way to survive, there is no place for principles. All men are the same and predisposed to want the same things, and this leads to war and violence. Those who claim peace are simply afraid of death. -men are equal unitis -men interact with no central authority -men are driven by certain motives: compitition, diffidnce-fear of losing something, and glory -Life is brutis and short with no right and wrong. No common power, law or justice

"Liberal internationalism" belief in international principles, trade to prevent war. Ideas derived from Kant.

Liberal Institutionalism The belief in international institutions and an inter-governmental body that has continuity in relations, trade, sanctions and embargoes, Reciprocity to address grievences, and a source of flow of information and technology.This model is non-state centric.

Mutual Assured Destruction (MAD) A condition of mutual deterrence in which, in the event of a nuclear war, each side has the capability to inflict an unacceptable damage on the other. Thus, neither side would presumably initiate the use of nuclear weapons. This situation necessitates both sides having sufficent weapons to retaliate (see second strike capability). From: How the World Works by Russell Bova

Nation, State, and Nation-state Nation-formed through the involvement of cultural, religious, and ethnic ties, not ideals State- primary actor in international relations. Components of a State: 1. Permanent population 2. Recognition from other countries 3.Defined territory 4.government capable of maintaining border. A state must be have a monopoly on the use of force and the power of taxation. Nation-state-the civic mechanics of a state combined with the ties of ethnic groups

NATO North Atlantic Treaty Organization (or OTAN in French) is the intergovernmental military alliance that was created in 1949 at the advent of the Cold War. It was the first contract of collective security that the US participated in. One of the immediate reactions was the creation of the Warsaw Pact between the Soviet bloc countries. The fundamental structure and function of the NATO alliance was the West against the Soviet Union, but has shifted since the fall of the Berlin Wall. NATO first saw action during the Korean War. France was resentful of the prominent roles of the US and Great Britain, and withdrew from the military component of the alliance in 1959. As the Cold War escalated, NATO played a consistent role, upholding the policies of détente, etc. At the end of the Cold War, NATO quickly became integrally involved in the crises in the Balkans. NATO had the flexibility to react with military might when the UN could not. There are currently 28 independent members from North America and Europe, who are committed to upholding the freedom and security of all the member states. See: http://www.nato.int/cps/en/natolive/index.htm

Non-tariff barriers (NTBs): non-tariff forms of restricting trade. These NTBs discriminate against imports and represent an exception to the free trade concept instituted under the GATT. Forms of NTBs include quotas, anti-dumping legislation, voluntary export restraints, and orderly market agreements, which are effectively multi-country VERs.

Marxism 1920-1990 founded by Karl Marx wrote the "communist manifesto" explaining how to live in a communist society

Milennium Development Goals In September 2000, world leaders came together at United Nations Headquarters in New York to adopt the United Nations Milennium Declaration, committing their nations to a new global partnership to reduce extreme poverty and setting out a series of time-bound targets - with a deadline of 2015 - that have become known as the Millennium Development Goals. See: http://www.un.org/millenniumgoals/bkgd.shtml

Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC): cartel in which many members are among the largest global exporters of oil. The purpose of OPEC is to regulate the supply of petroleum and thereby stabilize (often by raising) its price. OPEC was ascendant between 1973 and 1980 because of increased competition within the petroleum industry, increased producer-state bargaining, and increased oil dependency of the developed world. Saudi Arabia served as the lynchpin within OPEC, serving as a swing producer.

Peak Oil: where production is dwindling to levels inadequate to meet demand, which produces price spikes. Production can dwindle for a number of reasons included geology, environmental concerns regarding extraction, and the age of tough oil (oil is less accessible due to geopolitics).

Positive-sum: scenario in which all parties can gain or profit. In the liberal model of comparative advantage, through trade, all parties can benefit. In this scenario, one’s gain is not another’s loss. This scenario considers absolute gains, whereby you are better off than you were before, as opposed to relative gains.

Realpolitik: refers to a type of foreign policy, according to which concern for the security of the state (raison d’etat) is primary to any other concern, including ideology or moral dilemmas. Realpolitik also calls for pragmatism in calculating power and national interests by building military capabilities, creating alliances, or making concessions, which also reduce the chance of conflict.

See definition in this article

Realism; it analyses politics in terms of 'interests' as power. Realism tends toward a passimistic view of human nature and society, seeing conflict as inherent and inevitable. Classical Realism- Morganthaw- anarchy is assumed as a prominent concern in international relations,with the international system as the focus of analysis. States are hard-wired for power they seek more and more powerand this leads to war. -power is mans control over the minds and actions of other men -international relations is a struggle for power -states cannot die for a moral reason and cannot sacrifice themselves -no morality in international politics States are suspicious of other states, calculated, prudent and cautious, no permanent friends or enemies only permanent interests Neo-realism: Waltz- realism is a description of a system and states are trapped in a structure. like the classical realists, neorealist believe that anarchy exists. Countries create a distribution of capabilities and power--> relative gain. The primary goal is survival and the focus of analysis is power, and there is a clear distincition between domestic and international politics: -International Politics: states are actors, there is a lack of hierarchy, all states behave the same no matter their structure of government -Domestic politics: not all groups are egual, they are different units Realists – Bismark, Machiavelli, Kissinger – analyze politics in terms of power; conflict is the natural way of things

Relative gains

The benefits that accrue to a state from its international interactions assessed in comparision to the benefits that accrue to other states. Realists argue that states are most concerned with relative gains and that this concern is a source of tension and conflict in world politics. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova

Second strike capability The ability of a country with nuclear weapons to ride out an initial nuclear attack with enough retalitory capability left intact to do unacceptable damage to one's adversary. From: How the World Works by Russell Bova

Waltz's "Three Images" of International Relation In 1959, Waltz's book "Man, the State, and War" attempted to formulate a structural realist theory which classified theories of international relations into three categories, or levels of analysis. 1st Image: Individual, Human Nature. 2nd Image: State, Regime, Type. 3rd Image: System level (as a whole).

Uses of Force: For the following definitions see: International Politics, enduring Concepts and Contemporary Issues by R. Art and R. Jervis.

Defense: The defensive use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to do two things - to ward off an attack and to minimize damage to oneself if attacked. For defensive purposes a state will direct its forces against those of a potential or actual attacker, but not against his unarmed population.

Deterrence: The deterrent use of force is the deployment of military power so as to be able to prevent an adversary from doing something that he does not want him to do and that he might otherwise be tempted to do by threatening him with unacceptable punishment is he does. Deterrence is thus the threat of retaliation.Its purpose is to prevent something undesirable from happening. The effectiveness of the threatvdepends upon a sate's ability to to convince a potential adversary that it has both the will and the power to punish him severely if he undertakes the undesirable action in question.

Peloponnesian War: Greece 431-404bc. Thucydides was the first to write a purely human viewpoint in which he explianed the cause of the war was a distribution of power. REpresentation of Realist ideals. Struggle between Athen and Sparta because Sparta felt that Athens had become too powerful, the Coreyra/Corinth dispute, the sacking of pontideaea, and trade sanctions on Pegara Security Dilemma: A country can never fully know the intentions of its neighbors, making defensive measures appear threatening or aggressive, creating the security dilemma. This frequently leads to arms races, even if the countries involved have no intention of using force.

Sovereignty- comes from within a territory, having the authority to establish and enforce its own rules

Swaggering: The objectives for swaggering are more diffuse. Generally swaggering involves only the peaceful use of force and it aims to enhace the national pride of a people or two to satisfy the personal ambitions of its ruler. A state or a statesman swaggers in order to loo and feel more powerful and important, to be taken seriously by the others.

Treaty of Westophalia- 1648 ended the 30 years War, defined regions and abolished the hierarchy

Washington consensus: set of principles that informed economic liberalization policies of South in 1990s. Some of these principles were forced on the South by coercive actions of the U.S. or structural adjustment/austerity programs imposed by the World Bank and IMF. Others were adopted voluntarily. The consensus was focused on fiscal discipline, spending on public goods, tax reform, privatization, and deregulation.